Editorials thehindu.com

Finance Commission transfers and equity issue

The article analyzes the 16th Finance Commission's recommendations regarding fiscal transfers between the Centre and States, focusing on the vertical devolution share (retained at 41%) and the criteria for horizontal transfers. It highlights concerns raised by States regarding cesses and surcharges, fiscal pressures, and reduced fiscal autonomy due to Centrally Sponsored Schemes. The article details the 16th FC's adjustments to devolution criteria, including the introduction of States' contribution to national GDP with a square-root transformation, and the abolition of revenue-deficit grants. It discusses the marginal shifts in devolution shares among States and argues that the changes are too small to significantly alter the balance between equity and efficiency, with poorer states continuing to receive larger shares. The author suggests future FCs should emphasize fiscal capacity and outcome indicators and adopt more data-driven approaches.